×
Menu
Search

Can Children Express a Preference in Custody Cases?

When custody disputes arise in Illinois, it’s natural for parents to wonder how much say their children have in the process. Can a child choose which parent they want to live with? The answer isn’t as straightforward as you might think.

While Illinois courts value the wishes of the child in custody cases, the ultimate decision is based on what serves the best interests of the child. This principle ensures that the final arrangement promotes the child’s overall well-being—emotionally, mentally, and physically. Here’s what Illinois law has to say about the role of children’s preferences in custody cases and what parents need to know.

Understanding Parenting Time and Parental Responsibilities

Before we continue, it’s important to clarify the terminology. Illinois no longer uses the terms “custody” or “visitation.” Instead, these have been replaced with “allocation of parental responsibilities” (decision-making authority) and “parenting time” (formerly visitation).

Parenting time determines how much time each parent spends with the child, while decision-making authority refers to the responsibility to make important decisions about the child’s upbringing, such as education, healthcare, and religious matters. These decisions play a critical role in the court’s eventual determination in a custody case.

Can a Child Choose Which Parent to Live With?

Legally, No

Under Illinois law, a child under 18 cannot make a legally binding decision about which parent they want to live with. Minors do not have the legal authority to decide custody arrangements.

Practically, Yes

Although children cannot make the final decision, Illinois courts do consider their preferences alongside a variety of factors. The credibility of a child’s preference depends largely on their age, maturity, and reasoning. For instance, an older teen who can articulate clear, rational reasons for preferring one parent over another may have their opinion weighed more heavily compared to a younger child.

Age and Maturity Matter

While there’s no strict age at which a child’s opinion becomes relevant, older children (e.g., teenagers) who demonstrate maturity and understanding of the situation tend to have greater influence on the court’s decision. Conversely, a younger child’s preference may carry less weight, as they might be more easily influenced by emotions, gifts, or manipulation.

Factors Courts Consider in Custody Cases

Illinois courts apply a “best interests of the child” standard, examining multiple factors to determine an arrangement that supports the child’s health, stability, and overall development. These factors include:

  • The child’s wishes (balanced against their age and maturity)
  • The parents’ wishes, including their ability to provide a safe, nurturing, and stable environment
  • The health—both mental and physical—of the child and parents
  • Any history of abuse or neglect
  • The child’s relationship with each parent and any siblings
  • Potential adjustments the child might face, such as new schools or communities

Ultimately, a child’s preference is one of many aspects courts must review when allocating parental responsibilities and parenting time.

Commonly Asked Questions About Children’s Preferences in Custody Cases

At What Age Can Children Decide Where They Live in Illinois?

The only time a child can decide where they live is when they turn 18. Until then, their opinion is considered but does not determine the court’s ruling.

What Should Parents Do If They Disagree on Custody?

If parents disagree, the court will decide based on the outlined best interest factors. Seeking legal counsel from an experienced child custody lawyer can help present a strong case in court.

Are There Alternatives to Litigation?

Yes, many parents opt for mediation or agree on a parenting plan outside the courtroom. This collaborative approach often results in fewer tensions and smoother transitions for children.

Why Experienced Legal Guidance Matters

Navigating custody cases is often emotional and complex, especially when children’s preferences and best interests are at the heart of the matter. Understanding Illinois’ legal framework is essential for ensuring the best outcome for your family.

At Hammer Serna & Quinn, LLC, we are here to help. Our compassionate and experienced team understands child custody law, helping parents secure custody arrangements that benefit their children. Whether you need assistance with parenting time, allocation of parental responsibilities, or dealing with disputes, we’ll fight tirelessly to protect your family’s future.

Contact Us

If you’re navigating a custody case or have questions about the role of your child’s preferences, reach out to us for a consultation. Together, we’ll work to develop a strategy that prioritizes your child’s needs while respecting your rights as a parent.

share this post:
facebooktwitter

Blog Categories

Archives

Posts You May Like

When custody disputes arise in Illinois, it's natural for parents to wonder how much say their children have in the process. Can a child choose which parent they want to live with? The answer isn't…

Read More

Divorce is often a challenging and emotionally charged process. While many couples immediately think about heading to court, alternative options like mediation are worth exploring. But is mediation required in Illinois divorces? At Hammer Serna…

Read More

When a marriage starts to break down, the division of marital property is one of the most significant aspects of a divorce. This process can become even more complex if one spouse is accused of…

Read More

Get In Touch

Call or email Hammer Serna & Quinn, LLC today to schedule a consultation.